We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve your experience. This includes personalizing content and advertising. To learn more, click here. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies. Cookie Policy.

Features Partner Sites Information LinkXpress
Sign In
Advertise with Us

Download Mobile App

Radiologists Beat AI in Detecting Common Lung Diseases on Chest X-Rays

By MedImaging International staff writers
Posted on 27 Sep 2023
Print article
Image: Radiologists outperformed AI in identifying lung diseases on chest X-ray (Photo courtesy of RSNA)
Image: Radiologists outperformed AI in identifying lung diseases on chest X-ray (Photo courtesy of RSNA)

Chest X-rays are frequently used for diagnosis, but it takes a lot of training and expertise to read these images correctly. Although the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved some artificial intelligence (AI) tools to help radiologists, the real-world effectiveness of these AI solutions in radiology is still relatively unexplored. Previous research has often focused on the AI's ability to detect a single disease, which is simpler than real-world situations where a patient might have multiple conditions. Now, a new study of over 2,000 chest X-rays has shown that human radiologists were generally more accurate than AI in identifying the presence and absence of three common lung diseases.

A team of researchers at Herlev and Gentofte Hospital (Copenhagen, Denmark) compared the performance of four commercially available AI tools against 72 radiologists. They evaluated 2,040 adult chest X-rays from four different hospitals, collected over two years in 2020. The patients' median age was 72, and about one-third of the X-rays had at least one key finding. The researchers focused on three common conditions: airspace disease (which could be due to pneumonia or lung edema), pneumothorax (collapsed lung), and pleural effusion (fluid around the lungs).

The AI tools showed sensitivity rates that varied: 72-91% for detecting airspace disease, 63-90% for pneumothorax, and 62-95% for pleural effusion. When it came to airspace disease, the AI's positive predictive values ranged from 40 to 50%. In this particular set of older and complex patients, the AI incorrectly flagged the presence of airspace disease in 50-60% of cases. While these AI tools had a moderate to high sensitivity comparable to human radiologists for detecting these conditions, they were more likely to produce false positives.

Moreover, their performance dipped when the X-rays showed multiple findings or smaller target areas. For instance, the probability of a correct pneumothorax diagnosis using AI ranged between 56% and 86%, while it was 96% for the radiologists. According to the research team, the ultimate goal for radiologists is to strike a balance between identifying diseases and avoiding false positives. These AI tools, although not perfect, could act as a secondary check for radiologists, potentially increasing their confidence in making diagnoses.

“AI systems seem very good at finding disease, but they aren’t as good as radiologists at identifying the absence of disease especially when the chest X-rays are complex. Too many false-positive diagnoses would result in unnecessary imaging, radiation exposure and increased costs,” said lead researcher Louis L. Plesner. “Our study demonstrates that radiologists generally outperform AI in real-life scenarios where there is a wide variety of patients. While an AI system is effective at identifying normal chest X-rays, AI should not be autonomous for making diagnoses.”

Related Links:
Herlev and Gentofte Hospital 

Gold Supplier
Ultrasound System
Gold Supplier
Conductive Gel
Wireless Flat Panel Detector
ExamVue 10" x 12" Glassless Substrate Wireless
Silver Supplier
IMRT Thorax Phantom
CIRS Model 002LFC

Print article



view channel
Image: The researchers are using MRI-guided radiation therapy that pairs daily MRIs with radiation treatment (Photo courtesy of Sylvester)

AI Technique Automatically Traces Tumors in Large MRI Datasets to Guide Real-time Glioblastoma Treatment

Treating glioblastoma, a prevalent and aggressive brain cancer, involves the use of radiation therapy guided by CT imaging. While this method is effective in targeting radiation, it doesn't provide real-time... Read more


view channel
Image: The new ultrasound patch can measure how full the bladder is (Photo courtesy of MIT)

Ultrasound Patch Designed to Monitor Bladder and Kidney Health Could Enable Earlier Cancer Diagnosis

Bladder dysfunction and related health issues affect millions worldwide. Monitoring bladder volume is crucial for assessing kidney health. Traditionally, this requires a visit to a medical facility and... Read more

Nuclear Medicine

view channel
Image: A novel PET radiotracer facilitates early, noninvasive detection of IBD (Photo courtesy of Karmanos)

New PET Radiotracer Aids Early, Noninvasive Detection of Inflammatory Bowel Disease

Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), which includes Crohn’s disease and ulcerative colitis, is an inflammatory condition of the gastrointestinal tract affecting roughly seven million individuals globally.... Read more

General/Advanced Imaging

view channel
Image: Artificial intelligence predicts therapy responses for ovarian cancer (Photo courtesy of 123RF)

AI Model Combines Blood Test and CT Scan Analysis to Predict Therapy Responses in Ovarian Cancer Patients

Ovarian cancer annually impacts thousands of women, with many diagnoses occurring at advanced stages due to subtle early symptoms. High-grade serous ovarian carcinoma, which accounts for 70-80% of ovarian... Read more

Imaging IT

view channel
Image: The new Medical Imaging Suite makes healthcare imaging data more accessible, interoperable and useful (Photo courtesy of Google Cloud)

New Google Cloud Medical Imaging Suite Makes Imaging Healthcare Data More Accessible

Medical imaging is a critical tool used to diagnose patients, and there are billions of medical images scanned globally each year. Imaging data accounts for about 90% of all healthcare data1 and, until... Read more

Industry News

view channel
Image: Attendees can discover innovative products and technology in the RSNA 2023 Technical Exhibits (Photo courtesy of RSNA)

RSNA 2023 Technical Exhibits to Offer Innovations in AI, 3D Printing and More

The 109th Scientific Assembly and Annual Meeting of the Radiological Society of North America (RSNA, Oak Brook, IL, USA) to be held in Chicago, Nov. 26 to 30 is all set to offer a vast array of medical... Read more
Copyright © 2000-2023 Globetech Media. All rights reserved.