Features Partner Sites Information LinkXpress
Sign In

New Research Shows CT Scanner’s Benefits Offset Cancer Risks in Young Adults

By Medimaging International staff writers
Posted on 20 Feb 2013
Print article
The underlying medical conditions facing young adults who undergo computed tomography (CT) scanning are representative of an appreciably greater health risk than that of radiation-induced cancer from CT, according to new findings.

The study’s findings were published online before print on February 5, 2013, in the journal Radiology. CT utilization has grown approximately 10% per year over the last 15 years in the United States, raising worries of an increase in radiation-induced cancers. However, discussions of radiation-induced cancer risk often fail to take into account the condition of the patients being imaged, according to Susanna Lee, MD, PhD, chief of women’s imaging at Massachusetts General Hospital (Boston, MA, USA) and assistant professor of radiology at Harvard Medical School (Boston, MA, USA). “The impetus for our study was the concern that the lay press often focuses on potential harm caused to patients by CT imaging,” Dr. Lee said. “Lacking in this discussion is a sense of how sick these patients already are.”

To better determine the pros and cons of CT in young adults, the researchers, led by Dr. Lee and researcher Robert L. Zondervan, MS, studied imaging records of patients 18 to 35 years old who underwent chest or abdominopelvic CT scans between 2003 and 2007 at one of three university-affiliated hospitals in Boston. Children and young adults are more susceptible to ionizing radiation and more likely to live for the approximately 10 to 20 years considered necessary to develop a radiation-induced malignancy.

The researchers had access to records from 22,000 patients, including 16,851 chest and 24,112 abdominopelvic CT scans. During the average 5.5-year follow-up period, 7.1% of young adults who underwent chest CT scanning, and 3.9% of those who had abdominopelvic CT died—statistics that were much greater than the 0.1% long-term risk of death from radiation-induced cancer predicted by statistical models in both groups. “It was a bit surprising to see how high the five-year mortality rate was in this group,” Dr. Lee said. “To put it in context, the average young adult has only a 1% chance of dying in the next five years.”

The most typical reasons for exam were cancer and trauma for chest CT, and abdominal pain and trauma, and cancer for abdominopelvic CT scanning. Whereas many of the patients who underwent CT were cancer patients with a poor prognosis, Dr. Lee noted that the key differences in risk were evident in the other groups who had CT imaging, such as those suffering from trauma, abdominal pain, and difficulty breathing. “When we subtracted out cancer patients from the data set, the risk of death in the study group ranged from 2.5%–5%—still well above the risk in the general population,” she said.

Dr. Lee and colleagues also discovered that the patients who were scanned only one or two times represented the overwhelming percentage of scans. “This finding shows that radiation reduction efforts should also focus on patients who are very rarely scanned, and not just those who are scanned repeatedly,” Dr. Lee said.

Dr. Lee noted that the study group was imaged between 2003 and 2007, before radiation dose awareness and reduction programs such as Image Wisely and Image Gently took effect. She reported that the risk of radiation-induced cancer from CT in all probability would be lower today, making the difference in mortality even more pronounced. “We’re not saying be complacent about the radiation risk from CT,” Dr. Lee added. “But these people being imaged might have been in a motor vehicle accident, or have a perforated appendix or life-threatening cancer, and we’re trying to gain information from scans that can help them. That’s the part that gets lost in the debate.”

Related Links:

Harvard Medical School

Print article



view channel

Additional Aggressive Cancers Can Be Found Using Breast MRI Following Mammography Screening

The results of a study published online in the journal Radiology have shown that performing MRI scans, after the discovery of mammography breast cancer findings, sometimes shows larger and more aggressive tumors than those discovered in mammography. Breast Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is widely used for the screening... Read more


view channel

Fast, Noninvasive Assessment of Chronic Liver Disease Announced as Alternative to Biopsies

A leading ultrasound imaging vendor has presented the clinical benefits of its innovative technology for noninvasive assessment of the severity of liver fibrosis, at the Liver Meeting 2015, in San Francisco (CA, USA). Researchers have published more than 60 items on the reliability and effectiveness of the new technology.... Read more

Nuclear medicine

view channel
Image: Glioblastoma in a PET scanner with (left) and without (right) the YY146 marker (Photo courtesy of Weibo Cai, WISC).

Antibody Cancer Marker Causes Tumors to Light Up

A novel marker attaches to a molecule on highly aggressive brain cancer, resulting in glioblastoma tumor tissue being easily identified in a positron emission tomography (PET) scanner. Developed by... Read more

Imaging IT

view channel
Image: 3D scan a child’s heart born with congenital heart defects (Photo courtesy of the Phoenix Children’s Hospital).

3D Modeling System Accurately Predicts Pediatric Donor Heart Volumes

A new three dimensional (3D) computer modeling system may more accurately identify the best donor heart for a pediatric transplant patient. To develop the new 3D system, researchers at Arizona State... Read more

Industry News

view channel

Long-Term Strategic Managed Medical Equipment Services Partnership Announced

An 18-year strategic collaboration agreement, worth CAD 300 million, between a major medical imaging vendor and the Southwest York Region of Ontario in Canada, has been announced. The partnership is for managed equipment services to help advance medical technology in the Southwest York region, and to expand the accessibility... Read more
Copyright © 2000-2015 Globetech Media. All rights reserved.